Wasted Love - JJ
Austria has one of the most intriguing entries of the year and it will be a case study that will either put the pop-opera genre to sleep once and for all or it will revive it again.
'Wasted Love' is a classic specimen of pop-opera performed by JJ, a countertenor with some talent show experience. The first minute does build nicely but then the song barely progresses until we reach the final minute where pop-opera meets a techno/trance build up to further highlight JJ's vocal abilities (at least in the studio version). The song's only purpose is to become a vessel so JJ can showcase his voice and this has not worked most of the times in Eurovision.
Austria is currently leading the odds in the Winner's market @3.50, a price that is based on the assumption that they will landslide the Jury vote and will finish in Top-4/5 with the Public vote.
I do believe that the current odds are unrealistic and are criminally overpriced.
Austria has a very narrow path to win Eurovision. They will need 275-300 points in the Jury vote, preferably closer to 300, and then get at least 200 points in the Public vote, but neither of the two constitutions is guaranteed for them.
They need to achieve these numbers and at the same time Sweden must underperform with Juries or must not catch fire in the Public vote or both. Additionally, they will need France to finish lower with the Juries and be very close or lower with the Televote.
The chance that all the above mentioned possibilities happen at the same time is very thin and this is the main reason I do not think that Austria could be the Eurovision winner. I highly doubt that Austria can win Juries or even score 250+ points with them and their Cinderella story will end mid-way through the voting. But even if they score the magical 275+ points, I struggle to find a path for them with the Public vote. They will need a minimum of 200 points and this is where the historical data with the performance of pop-opera entries kick in.
Pop-opera has traditionally struggled big time in Eurovision and this is not the first time a pop-opera entry is considered a favourite.
Back in 2011 France was trading as low as 2.50-2.70 the day of the Final to end up finishing 15th! In 2015 Italy has sent Il Volo with 'Grande Amore', the only pop-opera entry that came close to winning, achieving a remarkable Public vote result (386pts - 1st) but finished just 6th with the Juries (171pts). With the 50/50 system they would have finished 2nd behind Sweden but with a 95 point deficit. And their odds were somewhere between 4.00-6.00.
Estonia in 2018 ('La Forza') was also considered a contender trading as low as 6.00 and was Top-4 in the odds for most part of the season. It finished 8th (6th with Juries, 9th with Public vote). A year later, Australia tried to follow the same recipe sending 'Zero Gravity', an entry that went under the radar pre-rehearsals trading at 200s and then caught fire and traded as low as 8.00. Another underwhelming pop-opera result finishing 9th (6th with Juries and 7th with the Public).
The main reason why pop-opera is a hit and miss is that the genre is not everyone's cup of tea. There will be jurors that will blank it and audience that will not vote for it. Having a great voice/impressive vocal abilities does not guarantee anything and most of the times these songs are perceived as show-offs or pretentious and fail to connect. But for some reason there is this notion that pop-opera is quality and especially Juries will bite and vote for it hence the single digit odds and favouritism throughout the years.
Add to all that the statements from the Austrian broadcaster about a staging that we have never seen before and the red flags are multiplied with the addition of the videoclip syndrome (entries that look/feel better on the music video but fail to bring/recreate the same concept/atmosphere on stage). Austria's recipe for success feels a bit forced/non-organic/Eurovision by numbers and this is the reason why I think it is not a winner and feels more like a wannabe/false contender.
Could Austria and JJ deliver a performance that will be mentioned for ages and will win Eurovision? It is a possibility, but for all the reasons I mentioned above, I believe it is safer to consider it an entry that could finish 5th-8th and with the perfect storm aim for a bit higher.
I will have an open mind for rehearsals but I doubt that Austria will crack Top-3.
What do I see in my crystal ball?
Austria failing to finish in the Jury Top-3 and Public vote Top-5 and end-up 6th-8th overall carrying the torch for pop-opera songs that did not live up to expectations...
Televoting Potential: 7.5/10
Jury Potential: 8/10
Staging Potential: 7/10
Momentum: 7/10
My Opinion: 7.5/10
Total: 37/50
What the fair winning chance % would be?
2% - 4%
Best case scenario:
Top-3
Worst case scenario:
Missing Top-10
Pre-Contest estimated points:
SF: 90-120
F: J: 125-200 - PV: 100-175 - Tot: 225-375
Share your thoughts in the comments area. Does Austria have 'The Package' that could secure them the win?
You can hear my thoughts about Austria in the 6th episode of the Eurovision Analysis podcast 'Talk About Things' co-hosted with the Eurovision experts @mat_rickard and @Panos_Zannettos at
Apple Podcasts Spotify